All Star Shore brought together 14 reality TV stars from around the world for its first season, creating one of the most internationally diverse casts in MTV history. Since the show’s second and final season wrapped in December 2023, the cast has kept busy — with weddings, babies, new TV appearances, and music careers making headlines on both sides of the Atlantic.Joey Esse, Angelina Pivarnick and Johnny Middlebrooks. Photo: John Phillips, Taylor Hill, Ben Symons (modified by author) Source: UGCTABLE OF CONTENTSKey takeawaysWhere to watch All Star ShoreSeason 1 cast — at a glance1. Marina Gregory — winner, The Circle: Brazil2.
Giannina Milady Gibelli — Love Is Blind3. Blake Horstmann — Bachelor in Paradise4. Bethan Kershaw — Geordie Shore5. Johnny Middlebrooks — Love Island USA6.
Joey Essex — The Only Way Is Essex7. Angelina Pivarnick — Jersey ShoreFAQsIs All Star Shore a dating show?Where can I watch All Star Shore Season 1?Where can I watch All Star Shore Season 2?Who won All Star Shore Season 1?Who won All Star Shore Season 2?Key takeawaysMarina Gregory won Season 1 of All Star Shore, taking home the $150,000 grand prize after she and her partner James Tindale won the final Shore-Down. Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli — who fell in love on the show — went on to have a son, get engaged, and marry in Croatia in June 2026.The Season 1 cast spanned reality shows from multiple countries, including Jersey Shore, Geordie Shore, Love Island, Love Is Blind, Bachelor in Paradise, The Circle: Brazil, RuPaul’s Drag Race, and The Only Way Is Essex.Joey Essex made history as the first-ever celebrity contestant on Love Island UK in 2024.The show has not been renewed for a third season since Season 2 wrapped on MTV in December 2023.Where to watch All Star ShoreAll Star Shore is an American reality competition series that premiered on June 29, 2022, on Paramount+. It is a successor to Jersey Shore, featuring television stars from around the world as they live together in a villa and compete for $150,000.
The series moved to MTV for its second season, which premiered on September 21, 2023. While the series left Paramount+ in the US, it continued to be available on the streaming platform internationally. Both seasons can also be purchased on Amazon Prime Video and on Google Play Movies.Season 1 cast — at a glanceHere is a quick-reference guide to the full Season 1 cast, their original shows, and their outcomes on the series.Cast MemberOriginal ShowOutcomeMarina GregoryThe Circle: BrazilWinner — $150,000James TindaleGeordie ShoreWinner (Co-winner of the Final Shore-Down) Karime PindterAcapulco ShoreFinalistRicardo SalusseRio ShoreFinalistLuis “Potro” CaballeroAcapulco ShoreFinalistVanessa “Vanjie” MateoRuPaul’s Drag RaceFinalistAngelina PivarnickJersey ShoreLost final ExileJohnny MiddlebrooksLove Island USA S2Lost final ExileBethan KershawGeordie ShoreLost final ExileBlake HorstmannBachelor in ParadiseLost final ExileGiannina GibelliLove Is BlindLost final ExileTrina NjorogeLove Island USA S3Lost final ExileJoey EssexThe Only Way Is EssexLost final ExileMike MulderrigLindsay Lohan’s Beach ClubLost final ExileChloe FerryGeordie ShoreWithdrew1. Marina Gregory — winner, The Circle: BrazilFull name: Marina GregoryNationality: BrazilianOriginal show: The Circle: BrazilInstagram: @marinavgregoryAll Star Shore outcome: Season 1 winnerGregory and her partner James Tindale went head-to-head in the final stage after winning the Shore Is Lava challenge.
Gregory won the final Golden Cup round, taking home the $150,000 cash prize, while James Tindale also shared the final victory as a co-winner of the season.Gregory was previously known for winning the first-ever The Circle: Brazil series, which is also when she came out as a bisexual woman. When she isn’t slaying the game on reality shows, the two-time winner is pursuing her dream as a singer.2. Giannina Milady Gibelli — Love Is BlindGiannina Milady Gibelli attends the Moana World Premiere at the Hollywood Bowl. Photo: Alberto E.
Rodriguez Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Giannina Milady GibelliNationality: Venezuelan-AmericanOriginal show: Love Is Blind Season 1Instagram: @gianninagibelliAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExileGibelli and Blake Horstmann met on the set of All Star Shore and celebrated their first anniversary as a couple in December 2022. Gibelli welcomed a son, Heath Orion, with Horstmann.Giannina and Blake are expecting their second child in March 2027, after tying the knot in Croatia in June surrounded by reality TV stars. The couple already share a 2-year-old son named Heath and have also launched a joint podcast, He Said, G Said.3. Blake Horstmann — Bachelor in ParadiseBlake Horstmann attends the 2022 MTV VMAs at Prudential Center.
Photo: Arturo Holmes Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Blake HorstmannNationality: AmericanOriginal show: The Bachelorette Season 14; Bachelor in Paradise Season 6Instagram: @balockaye.hAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExileHorstmann has built a career as a DJ, and has performed at EDC Las Vegas in 2024 alongside artists like John Summit, Dom Dolla, and Zedd, and brought the energy to Coachella 2024.Horstmann proposed to Giannina Gibelli, and according to People, the pair got engaged on October 30th during a trip to Madrid, Spain. They married on 20 June 2026. Their first child, Heath Orion, was born on March 29, 2024, and they are expecting their second child in March 2027.4. Bethan Kershaw — Geordie ShoreBethan Kershaw attending the Paramount+ UK launch event at Outernet London.
Photo: Ian West Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Bethan KershawNationality: BritishOriginal show: Geordie ShoreInstagram: @bethan_kershawAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExileBethan Kershaw is best known for starring in Geordie Shore, the international spinoff of Jersey Shore. On All Star Shore, she was partnered with Patryk Spiker from Warsaw Shore and became one of the season’s most talked-about personalities.During the show, Kershaw was in the news for her relationship with Johnny Middlebrooks. She has since remained active on social media, continuing to build her profile in the UK reality TV space.5. Johnny Middlebrooks — Love Island USAJohnny Middlebrooks.
Photo: Art Streiber Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Johnny MiddlebrooksNationality: AmericanOriginal show: Love Island USA Season 2Instagram: @johnny_lleeAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExileMiddlebrooks is known for coming in second place alongside Cely Vazquez on Season 2 of Love Island USA. On All Star Shore, Johnny Middlebrooks was partnered with Angelina Pivarnick and reached the final Exile round before being eliminated.Middlebrooks has continued to build his social media following since the show wrapped, remaining one of the more recognisable American cast members from Season 1.6. Joey Essex — The Only Way Is EssexJoey Essex attends the 2022 MTV Movie & TV Awards at Barker Hangar in Santa Monic. Photo: Amy Sussman Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Joey EssexNationality: BritishOriginal show: The Only Way Is EssexInstagram: @joeyessexAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExileEssex has appeared on numerous reality shows since TOWIE, including Splash! (2013), I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out of Here! (2013), Dancing on Ice (2023), and Love Island (2024).ITV introduced their first-ever celebrity contestant on Love Island when Joey Essex arrived as a bombshell on day one of the 2024 series.
He and Jessy Potts became the final couple dumped from the villa, subsequently entered a relationship, before splitting in September 2024.7. Angelina Pivarnick — Jersey ShoreAngelina Pivarnick attends the 2025 MTV Video Music Awards. Photo: Mike Coppola Source: Getty ImagesFull name: Angelina PivarnickNationality: AmericanOriginal show: Jersey ShoreInstagram: @angelinamtvAll Star Shore outcome: Lost final ExilePivarnick was one of the most recognisable names in the Sea
